Pay per lead: price it per job, not per lead

Pay per lead means you pay each time a potential customer contacts you, instead of paying per click or a monthly retainer. Whether it pays depends on your cost per booked job: the lead price divided by the share of leads you win. On Angi a request goes to "no more than five pros," and on Thumbtack a customer can contact five in the first four hours (help centers, read November 11, 2026), so a cheap shared lead can cost more per job than an expensive exclusive one.

  • How Google, Angi and Thumbtack price leads.
  • The break-even price of a shared lead.
  • Six lines to check in any pay-per-lead contract.

Free account review

Tell us where you are. We reply within two business days with what we would fix first.

Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid email address.
Please enter your website.
Please select a range.
Received.
We will reply within two business days.

01 — The terms

What is pay per lead?

Pay per lead (PPL) is a pricing model in which a business pays a set or bid price for each inquiry it receives, such as a call, a form or a message, whether or not it becomes a sale. In the U.S., "pay per lead" gets about 390 Google searches a month (Google Keyword Planner, November 11, 2026).

A shared lead is one inquiry sold to several competing businesses. An exclusive lead goes to one business only. Pay per call is pay per lead where only phone calls count. A lead credit or refund is money returned for a lead the seller agrees was invalid, usually to your balance with that seller. Close rate is the share of leads that become paying jobs. Cost per booked job is lead spend divided by the jobs it produced, and it's the number to compare, because every seller defines "lead" differently.

What U.S. searchers typeSearches a monthTop-of-page bid range
pay per lead390$11.70–$45.15
pay for leads140$14.02–$51.97
pay per lead real estate110$14.63–$56.13
pay per call leads90$12.10–$45.00
angi leads cost50$5.82–$27.15
thumbtack cost per lead50$1.90–$13.65

Source: Google Keyword Planner, United States, English, read November 11, 2026. Two top-ranking pages for "pay per lead" (Instantly, Service Direct) never use the word "exclusive" or "refund."

02 — Where you buy

How do Google, Angi and Thumbtack charge per lead?

None of the three publishes a fixed price list. Google says Local Services Ads lead prices "may vary depending on your location, the job type, the type of lead, or your bidding mode." Angi says lead fees "change based on task, homeowner location, and demand for the work." Thumbtack lets you set your exact lead price (help centers, read November 11, 2026). What differs is who else gets the customer and when you get money back.

SellerWho else gets itWhen you're chargedMoney backWhat you keep if you stop
Google Local Services AdsThe customer chooses whom to contact. Google prices a message lead partly on "whether the customer has contacted other Local Services advertisers."Answered calls, texts, emails, voicemails, booking requests, and missed business-hours calls over 20 seconds.Automatic credits for leads judged poor quality, duplicate or invalid within 30 days. None for "job type not serviced" or "geo not serviced," or for U.S. health care and tax specialists.Leads and billing sit in your own Google Ads account.
Angi"No more than five pros" per project request.When you and the homeowner have both shown interest. Leads are "not guaranteed jobs."Credit for invalid contact info, wrong ZIP, wrong service, a duplicate within 45 days or a charge while paused, if you tried calling within 24 hours. None on annual subscriptions. Credits expire after six months.The contacts you were sent. No ad account or ad history of your own.
ThumbtackUp to five pros in the first four hours of the search, more after that. The lead shows how many.Automatically when a matching customer contacts you, at the lead price you set. Opportunities are charged only if the customer replies.Automatic refund if the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours. Other requests within 45 days, "at our sole discretion," refunded to your Thumbtack balance by default.The contacts you were sent. No ad account or ad history of your own.
Pay-per-lead agency or lead vendorWhatever the contract says, and often it says nothing.By the contract's definition of a lead.By the contract's return window, if there is one.Usually nothing, if the ads ran in the vendor's accounts.

Sources: Google Local Services Help; Angi Help Center, including "How to Request a Lead Credit" (August 14, 2026); Thumbtack Help. All read November 11, 2026. Angi won't credit a homeowner who "hired another pro before you reached them" or "is gathering multiple quotes," because those cases are "accounted for in our lead pricing." Losing to faster competitors is already in the price.

03 — The math

How do you know if a pay-per-lead price is good?

Divide the lead price by your close rate to get the cost per booked job. The most a shared lead is worth is your cost per job from another source times the shared lead's close rate. A $50 lead you win 1 time in 10 costs $500 per job, and a $90 lead you win 1 time in 4 costs $360.

This is a worked example: one public benchmark plus our own assumptions. LocaliQ, which sells ad management, puts the 2026 average search ad cost per lead at $66.69 across industries and $90.92 for home improvement (published May 2026). We assume your own search leads close at 25%, or $363.68 per job, and test shared leads closing at 10%, 15% and 20%. Twenty percent is what you'd win if five pros had equal odds. The fastest pro wins more often, and the rest win less.

Your own search adsCost per booked jobShared lead breaks even at 10% closeAt 15% closeAt 20% close
You run them yourself, $90.92 per lead$363.68$36.37$54.55$72.74
50 leads a month plus a $900 management fee ($18 per lead)$435.68$43.57$65.35$87.14
20 leads a month plus a $900 management fee ($45 per lead)$543.68$54.37$81.55$108.74

Our math: break-even shared price = cost per booked job × shared close rate. The last row is where a management fee loses. Twenty leads at $90.92 is $1,818 of ad spend a month, which is below the $2,000 to $3,000 a month Eloari considers the sensible minimum for paid search. At that size, a shared lead that closes at 15% and costs under $81.55 beats paying us. A month of tagged calls gives you better close rates than any benchmark.

04 — What counts

What counts as a "lead" when you pay per lead?

Whatever the seller writes down. Since October 1, 2026, Google Local Services Ads has charged for a missed business-hours call when the caller stays on the line more than 20 seconds, and for a call that reaches voicemail, "whether or not they leave a message" (Google Local Services Help, read November 11, 2026). Angi charges once you and the homeowner have both shown interest.

Google won't charge twice for the same number or email within 15 days. But "business hours" means the hours on your Google Business Profile, so an unanswered phone between a listed 7 a.m. opening and an actual 8 a.m. start is billable.

Definitions have been fought over. In April 2023 the FTC finalized an order requiring HomeAdvisor, a company affiliated with Angi, to pay up to $7.2 million in redress. The order bars it from any false or misleading claims about its leads, "including that they concern individuals who are ready to hire a service provider" (FTC, April 2023). Nothing here says any seller misleads buyers today. The lesson is to get the word "lead" defined in writing.

05 — The contract

What should a pay-per-lead agency contract say?

Get six things in writing: what counts as a lead, how many buyers get each one, how you return a bad one, where the consent came from, whose ad accounts produce the leads, and how you exit. Without a written lead definition, a per-lead price can't be compared with anything.

Line to checkWhat a clear answer looks likeWhy it matters
Lead definitionA call of at least a set length, or a form with a working phone number, inside your service area and for a service you sell.Without it, a wrong number counts as a lead.
Exclusivity"Exclusive," or the maximum number of buyers per lead, stated as a number.It sets your close rate, and your close rate decides the price per job.
ReturnsA return window in days, the reasons accepted, and whether you get cash or only credit.Credit only helps if you keep buying.
ConsentThe form the customer filled in, and the seller names it listed.The FCC rule limiting consent to one seller was struck down in January 2025, so one form can still name several buyers.
Ad accountsWhose Google or Meta account runs the ads, and whether you can see it.In the vendor's account, the data and history stay with the vendor.
ExitNotice period, minimums, and what happens to phone numbers and pages.Tracking numbers and landing pages can belong to the vendor.

On consent: a December 2023 FCC rule would have limited consent to "no more than one identified seller," closing the "lead generator loophole." The Eleventh Circuit vacated it on January 24, 2025 (Insurance Marketing Coalition v. FCC), and the older written-consent standard stayed in place (Kelley Drye, January 2025). That's our reading, not legal advice. On phone numbers, see call tracking.

06 — Google's version

Is Google Local Services Ads pay per lead?

Yes. With Local Services Ads you pay for valid leads, not clicks, and the ads run on Search and Maps. Google is moving these campaigns into regular Google Ads as Performance Max campaigns with a pay-per-lead goal. According to PPC Land (July 20, 2026), "setting a maximum cost-per-lead is no longer supported" after the move.

The ceiling goes away, and the missed-call rule makes answering speed part of the price. The video covers both with a made-up house cleaning example. See also Local Services Ads management.

Google Local Services Ads Cost: The 20-Second Rule (Eloari, November 2026).

07 — The verdict

When is pay per lead better than running your own ads?

Pay per lead wins when your volume is too small to run ads well, when you're filling gaps in the schedule, or when you can't track calls yet. Your own ads win once you spend enough to read the data: you set the price, the customer contacts only you, and the account stays yours.

Your situationWhat's trueBetter choice
Under about $2,000 a month to spendA fee spread over few leads raises cost per job (the $543.68 row above).Pay per lead or Local Services Ads, tracked by job.
Nobody answers new leads within the hourShared leads go to whoever calls first, and Google now bills missed calls.Fix answering before buying any leads.
Filling a slow weekAngi and Thumbtack let you pause, cap the budget, or take one-off Opportunities.Pay per lead, as a supplement.
$2,000+ a month, and a job is worth several hundred dollars or moreExclusive leads, a price you control, and data you keep.Your own Google Ads, with Local Services Ads alongside.

Many businesses run several at once. Judge each by cost per booked job. See how to get more leads for what to fix first, and how to advertise your business for each channel's minimum test.

08 — Pricing

Does Eloari charge per lead?

No. Eloari Management Group, based in Davenport, Florida, charges a flat monthly fee from $900. The fee is never a percentage of ad spend, and there's no per-lead charge. You pay Google and Meta directly, and every lead comes from ad accounts opened under your business. Eloari doesn't sell leads and doesn't run Angi or Thumbtack accounts. It manages Local Services Ads as part of Google Ads.

TierMonthly feeSuited toIncluded
Starter$900/moAd spend under $5,000/moGoogle or Meta, conversion tracking, ad copy, monthly report
Growth$1,500/moAd spend $5,000–$20,000/moGoogle or Meta, call tracking, landing page testing, ad copy, biweekly review
Full$2,500/moAd spend $20,000+/moGoogle and Meta, full tracking stack, landing page testing, weekly review

No setup fee, month to month with 30 days' notice, and you keep accounts, pixels and conversion history if you leave. Jonatã Ariel Silveira, in paid media since 2012, runs the accounts himself. The typical fit spends $2,000 or more a month, with customers worth several hundred dollars or more. For click prices by trade, see how much Google Ads costs.

10 — Questions

Pay per lead: questions

How does pay per lead work?

You pay a set or bid price each time a potential customer contacts you, whether or not they hire you. Google Local Services Ads, Angi and Thumbtack all work this way. Compare them by cost per booked job: the lead price divided by your close rate.

How much does a lead cost on Angi or Thumbtack?

Neither publishes a fixed price list. Angi says lead fees change with the task, the homeowner's location and demand. Thumbtack lets you set the exact price you pay per lead, and a higher price makes you more competitive (help centers, read November 11, 2026).

Are Angi and Thumbtack leads shared?

Yes. Angi matches each project request with no more than five pros. Thumbtack limits a customer to five pros in the first four hours of their search and allows more after that (help centers, read November 11, 2026). Thumbtack shows on each lead how many pros the customer contacted.

Can I get a refund for a bad lead?

Sometimes, and usually as credit. Angi credits invalid or duplicate leads reported within 45 days, but not homeowners who hired someone else or were collecting quotes. Thumbtack takes requests within 45 days and refunds automatically if the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours. Google credits poor-quality Local Services Ads leads automatically within 30 days.

Is pay per lead better than Google Ads?

Below about $2,000 a month of ad spend it can be, because a management fee spread over few leads raises your cost per job. Above that, your own Google Ads give you exclusive leads, a price you control and data you keep.

11 — Next step

Start with the review.

Send your website and what you pay each lead source. We'll work out your cost per booked job by source and say which we'd cut or grow first, even if the answer is to keep buying leads.

Last updated · Reviewed by Jonatã Ariel Silveira, President
ELOARI MANAGEMENT GROUP, INC.
Davenport, Florida, United States
(863) 412-3323 · hello@eloari.com
Serving businesses across the United States
English · Spanish · Portuguese
Home · Pricing · FAQ